Issues of Patriotic Hysteria…
Why do most people attend church? Why do most don’t pee in public? Why do most avoid raping cute girls on the first date?
Each one of those questions asks the same thing. Although additional arguments can be made, the essential reason is “we want to belong”.
We want to belong to a civilized society of decent human beings (being tea bagged in jail might hinder that), and need to be seen as cultured and well mannered. The first question is the most vague one. It is almost as light as asking why do people jaywalk, in NYC, in groups. There might be many theories, but I still stick to any which connect the sacrifice of time (effort) to the price we are willing to pay to be considered a member of that (church) group.
So where does the subject line fit in?
During many Nationalistic movements, of all sorts, not belonging was “bad for your health”. Example of those movements are Bolshevik (Soviet Reds), patriotic hysteria after 9-11 (mainly in US), tragedy of Smolensk on April 10th 2010, and Nazi-Germany to name a few.
They all are very much different and I am far from putting the tragedy of Holocaust on a even level with 9-11 (it has been tried in US-TV and it was the biggest propaganda bullshit I have seen in a while, tragedy although large, isn’t even comparable…).
“Bad for your health”.
In each one of those cases member of those societies who didn’t agree with the current theme were considered… problematic. In Nazi-Germany and ZSRR you were eliminated, easy. In US since there was a need to control the population (haven’t made my mind up about it yet, conspiracy seems feasible) through propaganda and fear. Any opposition to the “official” story was considered unpatriotic and thus you weren’t an individual with a question or different opinion, you were a terrorist (your life got really bad if you were “born brown”). There was no defense against those accusations and only recently people started to talk about it… Side note: it was embarrassing how badly that was handled.
Either way, in each one of those cases there was a basic idea behind the nationalistic movement. Things mostly turned bad though. Those societies very quickly turned into either black or white. There was no middle ground, no shades of gray. You could be either with the theme or you were considered against. Lets add TV, religion and a old still healing wound (Soviet executions of 12000+ of Polish officers near the Katyn forests, recommend you check Wikki).
And so let us look at Poland. Seventy years ago Soviets invaded Poland (not long after Nazis did) and killed off thousands of officers and intelligentsia. Since then, Poland won its independence, started breaking ties with the communist party, became a part of EU and started slowly moving towards being a greater nation it once was. Soviet ZSRR changed too, it broke up and became Russia (there is still some history cover up, deep fried in secrecy, we will see what happens in the upcoming weeks).
Following the story, a Polish government group (way to many important people on one plane IMO) flew to Katyn, to celebrate the memory of the ones fallen (70th anniversary). They crashed, 96 dead (why? isn’t the top priority). Unprecedented, to have so many politically important people die at once, during peace time. Things started to happen, National Tragedy, a week long mourning, most of civilized world announced mourning days. Flowers started to pile up at Polish embassies around the world. Place before the Presidents Palace in Warsaw was (for days) swarming with people, candles and flowers.
Ready for the butts? I see couple of them and I am Polish.
President Kaczynski was a good person and started his career by being at the right place at the right time, accident or not, he was there. Politically wise he wasn’t spectacular and would probably end up having a paragraph or two in the history textbooks. He died in a terrible tragedy and suddenly he is getting elevated to a super-Pole. Every foreign dignitary (with couple exceptions) got the same memo (Wikki entry?) highlighting his greatness.
Suddenly everyone is getting bombarded by “greatness” info and looping on repeat scenes of the plane crashed in the mud. Depression is enhanced by media which afraid of playing anything else (un-Polish), play the same thing over and over. Patriotic hysteria sets in. To say anything but “we loved the man” or “it was terrible ::tear::” is un-Polish. So much for freedom of thought…
It is a tragedy, 96 very fine people died in a plane crash. Most people went to mourn with others, drastically reminded of their own mortality, which is understandable. To blow it up the way it was done is to make a circus out of something that is really sad. I suppose someone got a whiff of some international attention and it blew up.
That is not all, why would it end there? now comes the monkey act (see-do). To show how patriotic we are, “we” started to make Kaczynski one of the greatest Poles ever. That is not all, a new kind of panic, how can “we” match the insanity? … make him an honorary citizen of Warsaw, O.K. What else? …
In Cracow there is a massive necropolis in the crypts beneath the Wawel (castle). Only the greatest Polish people were granted a resting place there (people who take up chapters in history books). Idea comes across the screen, family is debating putting the presidential couple there. What? People woke up…
There were appellations made by bishops, to the crowds, to quietly accept this decision (catholic church hold a strong grip on Poland, it was their “un”influenced decision to allow burial there), but demonstrations still ensued. Argument? There is a problem when you start lowering standards for a place as important to everyone as are the Wawel crypts.
One last thing I’m going to mention is that Katyn was a Soviet doing, saying Katyn 2.0 is will build on the anti-Soviet sentiment which will translate into anti-Russian sentiment. From what I seen so far, Russia’s prim-minister and president behaved in a matter fitting the office they hold, very impressed and very happy.
Over all a great tragedy has been cheapened by people who had the power to use it for good. Voices can be heard that this tragedy is uniting people and reminding them of core principles of being Polish. However, most are just looking for company of living to be sheltered from the media assault. It is a tragedy that 96 dedicated people died in service of their country but you don’t have to give into the hysteria to prove you still love Poland.